After battling back to tie the game at 2-2 late in the third and securing a very important point, the Penguins failed to vault themselves ahead of the Detroit Red Wings for the second wild card spot thanks to a
Jake McCabe overtime goal. McCabe took a fantastic pass from
Auston Matthews, who scored goal number 65 earlier in the game, and beat an exhausted
Lars Eller to the front of the net before going five-hole on
Alex Nedeljkovic.