While, yes, you'd ideally like to see your stars all at or above a point per game every year, the fact of the matter is that the game calls for more than just point production and if a player is elite in other areas, sometimes it doesn't matter if they're not as productive on the scoreboard - especially when he's playing second fiddle to a guy like
Auston Matthews, who was well over a point-per-game last season and might score 60 or more again this season. It's also worth noting that Tavares would be a #1C on about 20-25 other NHL teams right now.