Recent Trade May Provide Good Insight on Nick Robertson's Trade Value for the Maple Leafs

As the Toronto Maple Leafs continue to roll, posting a 13-6-2 record and sitting at the top of the Atlantic Division despite numerous key injuries, some depth players have stepped up while others have not.

One player who has impressed since his call-up is rookie Fraser Minten, who has registered 1 goal and 1 assist in his first 2 games of the season.

In contrast, 23-year-old Nick Robertson has struggled, facing numerous healthy scratches, something Robertson has voiced frustration over in past seasons, claiming that he needs to play to make an impact.

However, his performance has not warranted a regular spot in the lineup, with just 1 goal in 18 games, matching Minten's goal output but in 16 more games.

A recent trade involving a similar player provides insight into what Robertson's market value could be. Nashville's trade of Phillip Tomasino -- also 23 years old and once a highly promising prospect -- could serve as a comparison.

After producing 70 points in his first 148 NHL games, Tomasino has struggled this season, registering only 1 assist in 11 games. A change of scenery could benefit both Robertson and Tomasino, as they are both clearly talented but may need new environments to thrive.

As Kevin Papetti noted on X:

Tomasino was traded to the Pittsburgh Penguins for a 2027 4th-round pick in a 1-for-1 deal. Given that Robertson has produced less and has had a less successful NHL career to date, it's likely he tops out at a 4th round pick in return, aligning with the current market.

While the Maple Leafs are under no obligation to trade Robertson if they don't like the return, the market for his services may have been set. If Robertson does not improve, especially with more opportunities arising from injuries among the forward group, the team may have little choice but to move him.

It's worth noting that head coach Craig Berube has surprisingly praised Robertson's play this season. However, his production of just one point is concerning, to say the least.