POLLS     NHL     SEARCH

Interesting Trade Proposal Emerges Involving Maple Leafs Defenseman Morgan Rielly Amid Rough Patch

PUBLICATION
Nick Matthews
January 22, 2025  (10:51)
SHARE THIS STORY

An interesting trade proposal has been tabled for the Maple Leafs defenseman Morgan Rielly as his ice time and level of play continue to dwindle this season.

While the Toronto Maple Leafs are enjoying a strong season, sitting atop the Atlantic Division with 62 points, one former cornerstone piece is slowly seeing his role on the team diminish. That player is 30-year-old Morgan Rielly.

Speculation has been swirling in Leafs Nation about a potential trade for Rielly, given his struggles this season, and one proposal might make sense for both teams involved.

As per Nealer on X:

"Hear me out: Morgan Rielly for Erik Karlsson."

At first glance, this trade idea might seem far-fetched, particularly with the salary cap complications. Erik Karlsson still carries a $10 million dollar cap hit for the next two seasons after the retention from San Jose, which could be difficult to make work.

However, it may be more realistic than it seems, as Kyle Dubas has been rumoured to be okay retaining some salary on Karlsson in order to move him.

As per Marco D'Amico on X:

"A source close to the Penguins has informed @TheRGMedia that Kyle Dubas is looking for a fire sale. Big name veterans, not simply just pending free agents, are up on the trade block and the Penguins are also willing to retain to move out Erik Karlsson."

With former Maple Leafs GM Kyle Dubas reportedly looking for a "fire sale" and being known for his loyalty to his players, there could be a trade opportunity here between these two teams.

Some believe that Dubas has already hurt the Penguins' aspirations, with many others expressing their displeasure with his moves since joining the team.

As per Spittin' Chiclets on X

"Kyle Dubas is looking for a fire sale?! What has this guy done with the Pittsburgh Penguins?"

While Karlsson may be 34 years old, he's only two years removed from a 100-point season and his third Norris Trophy as the NHL's best defenseman.

Though Rielly has long been a valued player for the Leafs, with trade rumours surrounding the defenseman, it might be time for a shake-up in Toronto. Perhaps there's no better player to pivot away from Rielly for than Erik Karlsson.

POLL
3 HOURS AGO   |   413 ANSWERS
Interesting Trade Proposal Emerges Involving Maple Leafs Defenseman Morgan Rielly Amid Rough Patch

Is Morgan Rielly still a top pairing defender at this point of his career?

MAPLELEAFSDAILY.COM
COPYRIGHT @2025 - ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.
TERMS  -  POLICIES